Lately in class we have been talking about the polarity between genders and the
dangers it can cause. In one exercise the class called out characteristics that
would be given to a man, and did the same for a woman. Most of theme
descriptions are what you would expect and cleary shows a separations between
the two. We have touched on the forces in the world that create these
distinctions whether it be through instances of "patriarchy" or just everything
we are subjected to. And now we introduce the variable of violence into the
mix. As stated in class, most rapes occur by men against women. We live in a
so called "rape culture" where nearly everything we see on a daily basis
suggests that women are merely objects.
On the topic of how what we see
in life directly relates to how we treat others, I think it just depends on the
person. We heard a statistic in class that said of all college males surveyed
56% said they would commit rape if they knew they could get away with it. I
find that number hard to believe. I am not saying rape does not happen at the
frequency stated in other facts, just that that particular statistic is hard to
swallow. As a man I have grown up seeing what all these men have, and Im not
out there just raping away. I watch plenty of movies where women are just in
them to be pretty objects held by the male hero. I have listened to rap music
with some pretty explicit lyrics towards women. Just because I see these things
does not mean I am going to go out into the world and do these things. This
reminds me of the debate of playing violent video
games and if these kids will go out shooting people in the real world.
Another argument deals with a kid who shot his school and blamed the shooting on
the fact that he listened to Marilyn Manson's music.
I think it is time
to change. First off we need to stop blaming other crap for our wrong doings.
No movie, tv show, music video, or any other type of media action should ever be
blamed for something a person does. Do we live in a rape culture? It is hard to
say, maybe its more accurate to say we live in a more provocative culture,
vastly different from the one our grandparents grew up in. I think it all comes
back to how we are raised. The values instilled upon us at a young age by our
family and friends will be with us much longer than some image we see in a music
video.
As for the way I was raised, I think my parents did a pretty
damn good job. I am the youngest in the family and did not really grow up
around girls, except for the older women in my family. I was always taught to
repsect the women in my life, rather that be friends or family or a partner. I
could never imagine hurting my mother, and because of that I will never be able
to harm another woman. I am strong and I hide my emotions like most men do, and
as suggested in the description of men. This does not mean I dont have
emotions. I have cried and without a doubt will again in the future. But I
will not cry in front of others. It takes something very personal for me to cry
be that the death of a loved one of the ending of a relationship. Because the
nature of me doing that is so personal to me I like to deal with my emotions in
the privacy of my own
home. Just because I look fine on the outside does not mean I am not
hurting on the inside. But I choose to deal with it in my own way, and that
means not letting others see it. Not because I think it is a sign of weakness,
just because I see it as a problem I have to deal with on my own. The notion
that we are growing a crop of emotionless guys is ridiculous. All guys hurt.
Thats a fact.
I think that's one of the things bell hooks was trying to argue in "Patriarchy," Alex. All people hurt--male and female. But where women are allowed to express their feelings, men are expected to suppress them, and this is oppressive and can even be damaging. From my own personal experience, I know when I hold back and hide the way I feel about something, I end up exploding.
ReplyDeleteI definitely don't think all guys are out there raping women--that's just silly. In fact, most men probably find the idea repugnant. But when we see images of violence against women perpetuated over and over, we become desensitized; it becomes more "ok." And I think the same is true with violence in video games; isn't that why the military uses video games to train soldiers?
I take issue with several points you make in this blog.
ReplyDeleteFor one, I don't understand why you don’t believe we live in a rape culture. You acknowledge that you believe rape occurs at the rates discussed in class. On the day we named our oppressions, nearly everyone in the class had been, or knew of someone who had been, sexually assaulted. In the face of both statistics and anecdotal information which confirm that rape is epidemic in the U.S., why do you question whether we live in a rape culture? Rape culture is not the same as “provocative” culture; suggesting otherwise blames victims of rape by implying that they provoke their attacker.
Furthermore, the concept of rape culture does not absolve rapists of responsibility. A person might commit murder because someone told them it would be okay – that still makes them a murderer, but it also implies a larger sociological phenomenon which needs to be explored and deconstructed. Also, no one is saying that our culture MAKES men commit rape; rather, the sustained atmosphere of violence against women and the belief that women are inferior to men (or, as Kirk and Okazawa-Rey have it, “systematic inequalities” between the sexes) combine to make many men think it is acceptable to harass or assault women.
Your disbelief in the estimate that 56% percent of college-aged men would rape a woman if they knew they would not be punished is also confusing to me. If 1.3 U.S. women are raped per minute and one in four women experience attempted rape in the lives, as we learned in class, then wouldn’t it make sense for a large percentage of men to be willing to rape?
I would also appreciate it if you would take the words PATRIARCHY and RAPE CULTURE out of scare quotes. I don’t know if it was your intention to question the validity of the words, but in any case the implied condescension of the scare quotes is very insulting to people who have experienced systematized gender-based violence and to people who suffer under patriarchy in everyday life.